How do they compare with regular canvas hunting pants for durability?
Looking at replacing my old canvas pants. They've held up okay but the seams are going. I keep seeing these newer synthetic blends mentioned. For those who've used both, how do they actually compare for durability? Specifically snagging on brush, abrasion, and how long before they just fall apart.
Depends on the weave. Heavy canvas will outlast most synthetics against thorns but it's heavier and stays wet. I've had good luck with a reinforced nylon faced pant. Two seasons on the same pair, no tears.
Canvas eventually rots at the crotch seams if you sweat a lot in them. That's been my main failure point, not the fabric itself.
This is the real issue. Thick canvas fabric itself is tough, but the stitching and the constant moisture from the inside is what kills them.
What brands are you considering? A lot of the durability argument comes down to the specific construction, like double knees or reinforced cuffs, not just the material.
I've used both for years. My take: canvas is tougher against sharp, pointy stuff. But a good synthetic blend will handle general abrasion, like rubbing against rocks or sitting on rough ground, just as well, and it dries much faster. The fast drying is a durability feature in my book, less time wet means less deterioration.
i've ripped the seat out of a cheap pair of nylon pants on a rock slide. never done that with canvas.
Fair point. There's cheap synthetic and there's good synthetic. I wouldn't lump them all together.
To me it's simple. If you're pushing through thick thorny brush constantly, canvas canvas. If you're doing more general walking and climbing, a good modern pant is probably more comfortable and will last fine.
This thread is helpful. I was about to buy a canvas pair but the drying time issue is a real concern for me.
"Less time wet means less deterioration" - This is what I was getting at with my first reply. The fabric abrasion resistance is only one piece of the puzzle. How it handles moisture and how the seams are constructed are just as important for long-term durability.
I've had the same experience with the crotch seams. It's the first thing to go on every pair I've owned. Never thought about the sweat being the main culprit before. Gives me something to look for in the next pair, maybe a gusseted crotch.
gusseted crotch is a must have for me now. makes a big difference.
Post a reply
Trending Discussions
- How heavy do these pants feel after a few hours? 12 replies
- I wanted to love my XKG Ridge pants, but something bothered me 10 replies
- What made you switch hunting pants brands? 14 replies
- What is the difference between moisture-wicking and quick-drying? 14 replies
- How do they feel when pushing through dense cattails? 11 replies