Which hunting pants have held up best against sharp shale, granite and loose rock?
I do a lot of spot-and-stalk in the Rockies and my last two pairs of pants got shredded in the seat and knees after one season. The rock is mostly sharp shale and granite scree, and I'm sliding down loose stuff constantly. Looking for real-world experience, which hunting pants have actually survived this kind of abuse without blowing out seams or getting sliced to ribbons? Budget is flexible but I'm not paying $400 for something that dies in a month.
Cordura in the seat and knees is the only thing that's lasted for me. I've been running the same pair of Kuiu Attack pants for three seasons now in exactly that terrain. The nylon face fabric is a bit noisy but it's tough. My buddy went through two pairs of softshell pants from a different brand in the same time.
following
Anything with a high nylon content and a ripstop grid has done well for me. I had a pair of Stone Glacier DeHaviland pants that took a beating on granite and only got fuzz, not holes. But honestly, the rocks win eventually. I've just accepted that pants are a consumable item up here.
Wait, are you guys actually sliding down scree in hunting pants? I just use whatever's on sale at the army surplus and accept that I'll look homeless. Never had a pair fail me yet because I never paid enough to care when they do.
I'll second the Cordura point but add a cvaeat: it's the seams that fail first, not the fabric. Look for double-stitched or bar-tacked stress points. I had a pair with great face fabric where the crotch seam opened up on a steep downclimb cuz they skimped on the stitching. Now I check that before anything else.
Not exactly a hunting pant but I've been using railriders or similar nylon canvas for years in the alpine and they're basically bulletproof against rock. You give up some stretch and they're warm, but I've never torn one on shale. Might be worth a look if you're not married to the camo thing.
Redtimber makes a fair point about the surplus stuff, but the fit on those old BDU pants is terrible for actual climbing and stalking. You get what you pay for in mobility at least.
Yeah thee seam failure is real.I've started reinforcing the inside of the knee seams with a quick stitch before the season starts. Takes ten minutes and saves the pants. Also, whatever you buy, wash it without fabric softener. Softener makes nylon break down faster in my experience, though I've got zero science to back that up.
Fabric softener thing is actually true-ish for some synthetics, it coats the fibers. Not sure it affects abrasion resistance much but it can't help. Anyway, back to the main question—has anyone tried the lighter weight Cordura pants? I want durability but I'm worried the heavier ones will cook me on early season stalks.
The seam reinforcement tip is useful, hadn't thought of doing that pre-season. I've been avoiding the heavier cordura for the same reason WapitiWidow mentioned—August scouting gets brutal. Might just have to buy a lighter pair and treat them as disposable and keep a heavy pair for the late season.
Post a reply
Trending Discussions
- Are Attack pants comfortable after getting wet? 15 replies
- Are Attack pants suitable for stationary tree-stand hunting? 10 replies
- Do you really need different pants from different hunting brands? 8 replies
- Why is it so difficult to find quiet hunting pants in larger sizes? 16 replies
- Is the XKG Ridge one of the better-value mountain hunting pants? 10 replies